Buy the MapSource TOPO U.S. DVD, 2008 on www.ems.com Print page iconPrint This Page
MapSource TOPO U.S. DVD, 2008 image
 
(based on 1 rating)
Brand: GARMIN
Online Retailer ID: 210256887
Located in: All Outdoor Gear, Books, Maps, Etc., Maps on CD
This TOPO® DVD features digital topographic maps for the U.S., including Alaska, Hawaii, and Puerto Rico. Downloadable to compatible Garmin GPS units.
Product Reviews Summary
Avg. Customer Rating:
 
(based on 1 review)

[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]

 
Errors and inaccuracies
By Dan from New Bedford, Mass. on 4/8/2008
Cons:
Too many errors
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend

I bought this product to use with Garmin eTrex Vista HCx GPS unit -- I liked the quality of the GPS unit so much I figured maps from Garmin would be of equally high quality, which is why I bought from Garmin instead of DeLorme. I wanted to use the maps in a variety of dayhiking, fishing, and flatwater paddling situations, so I'd have the convenience of lots of maps in a small unit.

After everything everything was loaded onto my GPS unit, of course the first thing I did was check my immediate location. The map got the name of my street wrong, and nearby it showed a street that doesn't exist. Well, every map has at least one error, right? But then I checked several other locations that I know well, and in half the cases there were serious errors. The worst error was two rivers that came together to form a stream -- that's such an obvious error that it's pretty clear that no one actually reviewed these maps at all.

Additionally, I was not pleased with the topo data. The contour interval is fairly large, which wasn't a dealbreaker for me. But when you zoom in to a map, the contour lines are jagged instead of smooth. The topo data might be adequate for driving, but is completely inadequate for even the most casual hiker.

At that point, I decided that I couldn't use the software for my intended purpose. In 30+ years of outdoors life, I've learned that it's not wise to trust inaccurate maps! But a casual user who didn't care too much about accuracy and just wanted to use the maps for fun might find this acceptable.

Eastern Mountain Sports Response:The product you may need is the US TOPO 24K National Parks, East v3. We currently do not have it on the website but it is in stores, and should be online shortly. The scale on this one is 1:24000 as opposed to the 1:100000, but only covers national parks, forests, and some state parks. It is as accurate as the most current USGS topos. It is also important that you insures you have updated the software version in your GPS along with checking to see if there are any updates to the mapping software. You can find any updates for both at http://www8.garmin.com/support/download.jsp. As far as the quality of printing maps, the National Geographic Topo program is way superior at, but it can’t upload topo data into the unit. Our first priority is your complete satisfaction with your Eastern Mountain Sports® purchase.
Please call us in customer service @ 888.463.6367, check out our website www.ems.com, or visit one of our EMS Retail locations if we can assist you in any way.
Customer Reviews about the MapSource TOPO U.S. DVD, 2008 at Eastern Mountain Sports
Powered by PowerReviews
Copyright © 2008 Eastern Mountain Sports All Rights Reserved. Do not republish contents.