By Erik The Boy Scout from Madison, CT on 11/9/2008
Best Uses:
Backpacking, Hiking
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
Even though I personally haven't bought this product or owned it I am a Boy Scout and one of the kids on a 50 mile hike let some of the kids in my troop use it. Within two days the thing worked horribly. They didn't follow the 8 liters to clean it, it was very hard to use.
By WRECKLESS from Steamboat Springs, Co on 9/13/2008
Cons:
Doesn't work right, Hard to Clean
Describe Yourself:
Outdoor Professional
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
I tried to use this filter for a through paddle of the Northern Forest Canoe Trail. I purchased one and tried to backflush the filter. It wouldn't work after that. So I bought another one. Same problem! Thought maybe the first one was my fault somehow. Just not a good product! I stick with my miniworks ex even though it is not at all light it survived a through hike of the Appalachian Trail.
Eastern Mountain Sports Response:We're certainly getting great and terrible reviews for this new filter. It’s rare to see a new product draw such a distinct line in the sand…either folks love it or hate it. If you haven’t returned or exchanged it already…we’d be happy to help you do so. There are plenty of good options on the market to choose from and would welcome the opportunity to talk about some alternatives. In the meantime we're welcoming any and all feedback regarding this filter and will continue to monitor the situation. If we can assist you in any way...you can reach us easily in Customer Service at 888.463.6367.
By greengoat
from New york, NY on 8/3/2008
Pros:
Easy to pump, Good filtration, Lightweight
Best Uses:
Backpacking, Hiking
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I have another water filter from MSR, which has always been slow, now unbearably slow, no matter how much I clean. I haven't even used it many times. Considering the slowness and the weight of the old one, I decided to buy another. This time I did my homework and researched it. I even tried a few other models and brands from my friends and asked them about the taste of filtered water. In the end I decided on this one for. After I bought it I tested at home. it is so far so good. Light, small and fast. I can't tell much about the taste of water at this stage and the filtering rate after it gets dirty a bit. I will do that after I tasted and tested it in the field.
Do not rely on this product!
By DBS from Milwaukee, WI on 7/31/2008
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
I have used this filter on 2 backpacking trips. It has to be cleaned so often its not even usefull any more. After a total of 12 days backcountry use, 4-8 liters/day, cleaning it every day, the filter hardly works any more. I am very disapointed in this filter. Get a Miniworks filter instead. If you carry this filter then be sure to have a backup method of purifing or you will end up boiling your water.
Eastern Mountain Sports Response:We hate to hear about gear not working for folks. This is the 2nd negative review on this filter which is suprising. That is exactly why we have our Satisfaction Guarantee. We want you to feel confident about shopping with us and we'll take care of you if your gear fails to meet your expectations. Our first priority is your complete satisfaction with your Eastern Mountain Sports® purchase.
Please call us in customer service @ 888.463.6367, check out our website www.ems.com, or visit one of our EMS Retail locations if we can assist you in any way.
By Scott
from Gilford, NH on 7/30/2008
Pros:
Easy to clean, Easy to pump, Good filtration, Lightweight, Low maintenance
Best Uses:
Backpacking, Day trip, Hiking
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I haven't used it too much but everything seems really simple to maintain and it does a great job. It's really lightweight so you won't mind throwing it in the pack.
By Struzel
from Camden, ME on 7/28/2008
Cons:
Hard to Clean, Hard to pump
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
No, I would not recommend this to a friend
As I planned a five-day hike of the 100 Mile Wilderness last week, I realized that a great way to reduce my pack weight would be to carry no more than a liter at a time and to drink 3/4 liter each time I filtered water. However, I had found that assembling and pumping a liter of water with the Katadyn Hiker typically took about ten minutes, time I did not want to spend 3-4 x daily. Consequently, the MSR Hyperflow held great promise given that it is carried fully assembled AND that it purportedly pumps as fast as a big squirt gun. Unfortunately, after the first two days, pumping the Hyperflow became excruciatingly difficult, despite my conscientious backflush cleaning of the filter daily. I assembled and reassembled numerous times, expelling all trapped air, and still no better. These efforts plus the constant concern that a dropped pack might fracture the filter without any obvious sign of fracture made the whole process quite annoying. In the field, doing the backflushing every 8 liters, and checking for a broken filter by the bubble test is really quite problematic. Finally, the claimed weight of 7.5 ounces is inaccurate. The assembled unit with its little carry case weighs 10 ounces, only 2.5 ounces less than the much more reliable Katadyn Hiker.
Eastern Mountain Sports Response:We are shocked to learn of your experience with the Hyperflow Microfilter. This is exactly why we have our Satisfaction Guarantee. We want you to feel confident about shopping with us and we'll take care of you if your gear fails to meet your expectations. Our first priority is your complete satisfaction with your Eastern Mountain Sports® purchase.
Please call us in customer service @ 888.463.6367, check out our website www.ems.com, or visit one of our EMS Retail locations if we can assist you in any way. This filter did win the Backpacker Editor's Choice Award this year (2008)...and they had this to say about it..."If you think water filters are slow, heavy, and prone to clogging, we have a message: You're wrong. The HyperFlow is so fast and light it converted several editors who had sworn off filters in favor of chemical treatment. The secret is in the filter cartridge. It's the size of a fat Sharpie marker, and it houses a bundle of hollow, porous tubes; water is forced through the open end of the tubes and then filtered through tiny pores. And it does this at the astounding rate of 3 liters per minute. "The biggest bummer with water filters has always been the time they require, which is only compounded as your group size grows," remarked one tester. "No more. This baby cranks!" The whole system, which includes a wire-mesh pre-filter, packs down to the size of a small bike pump and weighs less than a cup of water. The HyperFlow filters nasties as small as .2 microns, which removes protozoa (like giardia and cryptosporidium) and bacteria (like E. coli), but not viruses. MSR claims a filter cartridge lifespan of 1,000 liters, and during six months of field-testing we didn't experience a single slow-down."
By TD
from Orange County, CA on 6/1/2008
Pros:
Easy to clean, Easy to pump, Good filtration, Lightweight
Best Uses:
Backpacking, Hiking
Describe Yourself:
Casual/ Recreational
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Lightweight so its perfect for backpacking. Filters water incredibly fast with minimal effort.
[1 of 1 customers found this review helpful]
Fast, efficient, and light...
By SLJ on the Appalacian Trail
from NY, NY on 5/29/2008
Pros:
Easy to pump, Good filtration, Lightweight
Cons:
Maintenance of valves
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
I used to use the miniworks and wanted to lighten my load. This filter is amazing- its so light, easy to use, great taste of water, and easy to pump (seriously takes 1 minute to fill the nalgene). Beware of trail maintanence as you must flip the filters and reverse pump every 8 liters.
By Jim
from Boston on 5/29/2008
Pros:
Easy to pump, Lightweight
Describe Yourself:
Avid Adventurer
Bottom Line:
Yes, I would recommend this to a friend
Haven't had a chance to thoroughly test, but seems great thus far.